Thursday, 6 November 2014

Visual puns and optical illusions by Shigeo Fukuda

"Never state what can be implied." - James Wong Howe

An opening paragraph in Shigeo Fukuda's "Hall of Fame" article on the American Design Council's website reads: "The Japanese, being culturally homogenous, need not articulate everything in order to be understood.  They believe in more indirect and abstract forms of expression." (1987)
I fist came across the work of Shigeo Fukuda in the book Graphic Agitation, which I wrote about in a post this week.  His work stood out as one I could use in my concept development research as much of it is propagandic but with a commercial style and a sense of humour.  

"Discovered" by Paul Rand, who brought Fukuda to the American audience, Fukuda's signature style in printmaking is is heavily influenced by the Swiss style - flat and 2-dimensional.   Much of his illustrations form optical illusions often created with human figures or limbs, and are intended to be humorous.  I think the element of surprise is effective in making the work resonate with people on a deeper level; Fukuda was vocal about his work making a social impact and by creating works that invited a second look.  Humour also disarmed the viewer, and even if they were not inclined to agree with the message, the image would be memorable.  

Fig. 1

Above: "All Flesh is Grass", a simple but visually engaging print which reminds the viewer that the crops and pastures herbivores eat needs to be taken care of and not polluted.

  Fukuda's art comes under the "propagandist" umbrella as many of his works were created to raise awareness of environmental and social issues.  "Fukuda's sense of high moral responsibility as a graphic designer is undertake with firm conviction.  His work effectively mirror and embraces the worldly causes he believes in.  Coupled with his fine flat for colour and layout, along with advanced Japanese reproduction techniques, Fukuda always manages to get his point across. " (1987) A key example is his body of work for Earth Day.  In the example shown in Fig.  2, an axe is shown as a metaphor for deforestation issues.  The little sapling brand sprouting from the handle represents the environmental struggle, with that little bit of hope.  

Fig. 2
 A second example (Figure 3) shows an image of the globe as a sprouting seed, emphasising the issues with the eco-system.  Figure 4 shows arms encircling the world, with the shape being completed as a handshake.  The metaphor is clear - respect, co-operation and care is needed to help the planet.   The article notes that "Fukuda's pro-environmental concepts are indeed abstract, yet globally familiar." (1987)  Even a non-English speaker can understand the visual message in Fukuda's pieces.

Fig. 3

Fig. 4
Another series of images, Environmental Pollution, subverts everyday household products into images that suggest harm and destruction.  Sharp ends of scissors, an open safety pin needle and a giant screw  - the images associated with producing goods have been turned on their head to suggest the dangers we often overlook.  The metaphors are subtle, but the readable text "Environmental Pollution" helps to prompt the viewer to understand the link between the two.  By over-producing goods and subsequently creating pollution and a large carbon footprint, manufacturers are causing a detriment to the environment.  "Contrary to Western styles of expression, Japanese communication is more emotional than rational.  Such emotion is profoundly linked to art.  Fukuda dramatically shatters all cultural and linguistic barriers with his universally recognisable style." (1987)

Fig. 5
Fig. 6

Fig. 7





Fukuda's commercial illustration is also worth noting, as the playful use of negative space holds a visual rhetoric to his which is similar to his political pieces in that they make the viewer stop and investigate the image.  Figure 6 is an advertisement for UCC Coffee, a coffee company that uses ethically sourced coffee beans.  The image is composed to look like the swirl of coffee in a mug as it is being stirred with milk, and this is cleverly constructed with hands holding coffee cups protruding from both the black and negative spaces.  The impression is that of a coffee company advertisement that shows the company's commitment to people and quality.  Figure 5 was used to advertise a Fukuda art show in 1975, perfectly showcasing the essence of his optical, stark and often witty style.  

Figure 8






Figure 9

Above: a fantastically simply illustration for "The Marriage of Figaro", an opera buffa about a group of people all scheming to marry each other off in revenge for deeds done in a previous play.  Fukuda showcases the subjects of music and sexual politics through turning a treble clef into an illusion which gives the impassion of a man and woman tangled up in each other.


Fukuda's most famous piece of work, "Victory 1945",  won various awards for it's simplistic approach to the issue of war.  The image is at first glance a funny one, as the sexual pun is so in-your-face, but underneath it is also a sharp criticism of the nuclear war.  

Fig 12
Fig 13
In a similar vein, No More War (above) shows a skull created with an assemblage of missiles.  Fukuda's stance on raising awareness of global issues was inspired by Takashi Kono, a graphic artist who had leanings towards propagandic messaging in his works .  At the time Kono was working in the industry, there was a surge of Western (particularly American) creative influences which were chipping away at the traditional Japanese ideas.  His work features typical subject matter of Japanese art such as mountains, flowers, koi fish etc, but without the traditional aesthetics.  An example of this is the blocky giesha composition, which is far removed from the style associated with Peter Paul Rubens and traditional Japanese art (Figure 12).  

Fig 14
Fig 15

A lot of Kono's work criticised this American influence - Figure 13, Sheltered Weaklings Japan, shows a school of little fish with the Japanese flag following a much larger, predatory-looking American fish.  The two red fish swimming in the opposite direction represent the U.S.S.R and China, the two political giants in the Cold War.  Kono's opinion on the political proceedings is clear here, as is an indication of what he wants to change.  There is not much else I can find of Kono's work as it is protected by data laws, but it was useful to look at what I could find.  It is easy to see how the ideas and presentation influenced Shigeo Fukuda's artistic voice.  

Fukuda's work ties in with my propagandic research as well as the theme of simplistic illustrations using shape and colour (see "An Exercise In Shapes").  My interest is in visual rhetoric which Fukuda has used again and again with great effect.  His most famous quote that sums his approach up"

"I believe that in design, 30 percent dignity, 20 percent beauty and 50 percent absurdity are necessary" - Shigeo Fukuda.  


-

References

Unknown, 1987.  Shigeo Fukuda. [online article] Available at: http://adcglobal.org/hall-of-fame/shigeo-fukuda/ [Accessed 6th November 2014]

Images

All by Fukuda, Shigeo:

Figure 1: All Flesh Is Grass [online image] Available at  http://australianposterbiennale.com/other/poster-greats/
[Accessed 6th November 2014]

Figure 2: 1982, Earth Day [online image] Available at:
http://gurafiku.tumblr.com/post/5099970531/japanese-poster-happy-earthday-shigeo-fukuda
[Accessed 6th November 2014]

Figure 3: 1982, Earth Day 2 [online image] Available at:
http://images.lib.ncsu.edu/luna/servlet/view/all/who/Fukuda,%20Shigeo/what/Graphic%20Design?sort=WORKTITLE,AGENTSORTNAME,IMAGEID,TITLETEXT
[Accessed 6th November 2014]

Figure 4: 1982, Earth Day 3 [online image] Available at:
http://images.lib.ncsu.edu/luna/servlet/view/all/who/Fukuda,%20Shigeo/what/Graphic%20Design?sort=WORKTITLE,AGENTSORTNAME,IMAGEID,TITLETEXT
[Accessed 6th November 2014]

Figure 5: 1973 Environmental Pollution [online image] Available at:
http://australianposterbiennale.com/other/poster-greats/
[Accessed 6th November 2014]

Figure 6: 1973 Environmental Pollution [online image] Available at:
http://australianposterbiennale.com/other/poster-greats/
[Accessed 6th November 2014]

Figure 7: 1973.  Evironmental Waste [online image] Available at:
http://gurafiku.tumblr.com/tagged/shigeo+fukuda/page/4
[Accessed 6th November 2014]

Figure 8: 1975. Shigeo Fukuda Exhibition [online image] Available at:
http://gurafiku.tumblr.com/tagged/shigeo_fukuda
[Accessed 6th November 2014]

Figure 9: 1984. UCC Coffee [online image] Available at:
http://gurafiku.tumblr.com/tagged/shigeo_fukuda
[Accessed 6th November 2014]

Figure 10: International Carpet Design Competition [online image] Available at:
http://www.itsnicethat.com/articles/shigeo-fukuda
[Accessed 6th November 2014]

Figure 11: 1981, The Marriage of Figaro [online image] Available at:
http://gurafiku.tumblr.com/tagged/shigeo+fukuda/page/2
[Accessed 6th November 2014]

Figure 12: 1971.  Victory [online image] Available at:
http://gurafiku.tumblr.com/tagged/shigeo+fukuda/page/5
[Accessed 6th November 2014]

Figure 13: 1968. No More War [online image] Available at:
http://gurafiku.tumblr.com/tagged/shigeo+fukuda/page/3
[Accessed 6th November 2014]

Figure 14: Kono, Takashi. Japan. [online image] Available at:
http://c20thgraphicdesign.blogspot.co.uk/2008/06/leilani-takashi-kono.html
[Accessed 6th November 2014]

Figure 15:  Kono, Takashi, . Sheltered Weaklings - Japan [online image] Available at:
http://22-2400.blogspot.co.uk/2012/02/sheltered-weaklings.html
[Accessed 6th November 2014]































Visit to DCA

Thanks to Dave, this afternoon myself and a few classmates visited the Visual Arts Research studio at Dundee Contemporary Art, where we got a tour of the studio and watched various techniques being done by people who work there.  It got me thinking a lot about the physical techniques I could use to create work, in particular screen printing which is often used in propagandic work.  I knew I really wanted to create something physical as well as digital, but I hadn't considered prints or posters (which is strange seeing as all the work I have been looking that is printed).   My plan for the next month is to create a brand identity and advertisements with elements of styles which are associated with either overt propaganda (think Obey by Shepard Fairey) or more contemporary styles.  There is a screen printing workshop running next weekend, which I plan on going along to to make some stuff which should hopefully contribute to pre-production.  

As well as screen printing, I was especially interested in the work created by lenticular (holographic printer).  A little while ago I looked briefly into afterimageing and optical art, which I sort of abandoned as other ideas took precedence.  I still really love the idea of creating works that subvert images in quite a literal way, and since the DCA offer workshops I hope to get the chance to make some either in time for hand in on the 8th of December or after.  Holographs could be used to create "animated" posters, with an approach of "this is not what it first seems" as the message.   We were also shown how the laser cutter works, which I am keeping in mind for future practise. 


Wednesday, 5 November 2014

Modern propaganda - OBEY by Shepard Fairey

"The real message behind most of my work is: question everything" - Frank Shepard Fairey

OBEY is the brainchild of Frank Shepard Fairey, a graphic and street artist who is best known for the famous "Hope" poster for Barack Obama's presidential campaign in 2008 as well as the aforementioned project.   The tagline for the company is "Manufacturing Quality Dissent since 1989", a tongue in cheek hint that Fairey's work is intended to stir people up.

 For me, it was an interesting observation in how a brand can become de-contextualised when I found out that OBEY was not a fashion brand that thrived on "logo-status".  I had seen the logo plastered on T-shirts and snapback caps and assumed it was a line that sold based on some cult status hype, in the same way that a navy hoodie with Abercrombie and Fitch on the chest will be coveted much more than a plain navy hoodie.  What I found was a contemporary propaganda project that brings to light political imbalances in the US in a way that invites people to participate by buying the prints.

OBEY stemmed from a work of art Fairey created in college, titled Andre the Giant has a Posse.  On the OBEY Giant website, Fairey writes: "The sticker has no meaning but to cause people to react, to contemplate and search for meaning in the sticker." (Fairey, 2011)  The subject matter, Andre the Giant was chosen by Fairey because he had an unpleasant face and was dead, which made many believe Fairey was actually criticising the way dead celebrities are iconised in Western culture.  The image (fig) was made into stickers and placed around Providence, where it was illegal to do so, and therefore forming a basis for Fairey to protest against corporate ad space.  Soon after this he noticed that his creations were getting more attention from the public than he had anticipated.  In an interview for AIGA, he explained that "When I started to see reactions and consider the sociological forces at work surrounding the use of public space and the insertion of a very eye-catching but ambiguous image, I began to think there was the potential to create a phenomenon." (Fairey interviewed by Heller, 2004)  This led to a desire to spread the image outside of Providence, where Fairey lived at the time, and create a momentum that could lead to a small cultural shift.


Fig. 1 Andre the Giant Has A Posse



 On why many people were intrigued by the sticker and willing to get involved, Fairey said: "I think a lot of people liked the idea of 'fucking with the program' in a society dominated by corporate imagery.  The stickers were a rebellious wrench in the spokes, a disruption of the semiotics of consumption."(Fairey interviewed by Heller, 2004)  This developed into a movement of 'respectful' propagandic art, where Fairey would only stick his works on public property or on the backs of signs and electrics boxes in a way that he would not deface them.

"More Milliterry Less Skools" (Figure 2) is a criticism of the Bush administration and the decision to go to war in Iraq.  By using bad grammar as the central point of the poster, Shepard's opinion on the politics of the time and the impact it could have on education in the US (as much-needed education funds were being cut in favour of military spending) is clear.  The poster appears in a similar visual style to a dollar bill, adding a secondary layer to the message, and the classic slogan "In God We Trust" is mocked with a re-interpretation: "In Lesser Gods We Trust".  In a similar vein, "Scale Tipping Services" (Figure 1) print uses the metaphor of death, money and the uneven scales held by Lady Justice (an American symbol of freedom) to present the situation in Washington, aka US government headquarters.   In his works that criticise the government system, Fairey makes use of a patriotic colour scheme or identity - "Scale Tipping Services" matches colour schemes with the star-spangled banner and "More Millitery Less Skools" evokes the look of American dollar bills.


Fig.2 Scale Tipping Services, 2013

Of "Scale Tipping Services", Fairey wrote on his online gallery that "Corporate donations distort their influence in politics and corrupt our democracy…it effects (sic) all Americans by insuring (sic) that corporate interests are put before the interests of the average person.  Genuine democracy should guarantee that politicians create the greatest good for the greatest number of people, but that idea has eroded with the favours owed by politicians to corporations in exchange for their contributions."  The poster was created in collaboration of ideas with Josh Silver, who was leading a grassroots movement to counter anti-voting rights in Montana, and was designed to add to the momentum. 
Fig 3.  More Militerry Less Skools, 2013



Fig 4. Home Invasion 2

This image has a layered message.  At first glance it looks like a promo for gun crime, but at a closer inspection you can see there is a camera aperture in the barrel of the gun which is smoking, given the impression of a shot being fired and a photography being taken.  The tagline at the footer reads "Oppose intrusive surveillance and invasions of privacy", which explains the point of the poster.  Fairey has created a sly visual pun by subverting the message of gun crime into that of personal privacy.  The poster was released in February 2014, around the time that it was becoming apparent that the government had been essentially spying on civilians through their private online correspondence.  The composition of the poster suggests something imposing, unavoidable and intimidating - the metaphor of a gun being pointed in your face is a device that highlights the unethical practise of the digital privacy invasion.   Using the page of a gun is a clever method as the outcry against digital surveillance has not really come into the limelight yet as a movement, whereas the push for anti-gun laws is added to every time there is a national crime so it is widely recognised and paid attention to.  Another example of a subversion of a traditional advertisement is "Paint It Black" (below).

Fig 5. Paint It Black 
"Paint It Black" is a similar criticism of 'the corrupt system', in this case the exploitation of oil and how it dictates foreign policies.  Fairey writes on the webpage that he deliberately aimed for a propagandic look in this piece of work; his influences from Constructivism really shows through here, in particular with the colour palette (that telltale red!), and the angular lines which frame the greyscale illustration.  The clever manipulation of a vintage paint label - "indoor/outdoor hazardous", "cover it all" speaks to the hold that oil currency has over the United States' economy and the negative effect it has.  "Imagine if all the money spent on wars and strategic interests in the Middle East had been spent on developing green energy alternatives.  Instead, out government subsidises the highly profitable oil and gas industries for $40 billion a year because no politician wants a rise in the price of gas to be blamed on them." (Fairey, 2014)  Another recent work, "Paradise Turns", mimics an idyllic beach being slowly infringed upon by an oil plant, in the style of a vintage postcard.  

Fig 6. Paradise Until The Tide Turns


What I find interesting about these pieces is the intention for the prints to look like propaganda, particularly with the vintage style.  A question that is running through my research at the moment is what kind of propaganda is the most effective.  If it is openly propagandic as the images are, would people allow themselves more easily to be swayed by the message, or would they feel as though they should ignore it as it was perhaps an idea being 'forced' on them visually?  After completing an online survey for another student the other day, I am feeling more and more that I should take the same approach with images such as these ones as the subject matter.   In an interview with AIDA, Shepard Fairey makes a point that stood out to me for consideration: "(My work) would be embraced by people who shared the same opinion, and be instantly rejected by anyone who saw it as issued by the enemy.  Obey seemed to get under people's skin because they didn't know what to make of it.  The ambiguity promoted a death about the intent of Obey and got a lot of issues out on the table that people would not have discussed if they were able to classify and immediately ignore it."(Fairey interviewed by Heller, 2004)

Fig. 7 People's Climate March, 2014
This poster was created as a free-for-download in the run up to the People's Climate March, a further example of Fairey's art contributing to the momentum of a campaign.  The imagery of Lady Liberty sinking is a clear metaphor to Americans about the possibility of what could happen if climate change is ignored.  Of his overtly political stance, Fairey said in an interview with Heller (2004) "I feel we are in a time of crisis and there is no time to be wasted allowing people to have epiphanies about authority, conspicuous consumption, and the control of public space at the rate that best suits them." The BNE x Shepard Fairey print below (Figure) was designed in conjunction with campaigner BNE, to bring safe clean water to India.  This image is very similar to Figure 7 in both colour palette and handling of the subject matter - there are no cheeky metaphors, instead imagery that brings the audience face to face with a situation.   Here we can touch upon the brand element of Obey and Shepard Fairey's work, which has an illustration style that is now a recognisable identity for the company.  The graphic style is influenced by Andy Warhol, the Constructivists and skateboard culture, all of whom have in common the desire to subvert traditional messages in order to being about change.  The bright palettes are simple but highly saturated so attract the eye in the first place, and the subject matter is illustrated in a way that is high impact.

Fig. 8 BNE x Shepard Fairey

"Many people feel powerless and my goal is to show that one person can have an effect on things even with limited resourced.  Whether this manifests itself with people in the form of street art or a magazine or a band, I'm hoping to encourage D.I.Y (do it yourself ethics)." 

I have barely touched the surface of Fairey's portfolio of work, and I have noticed that some work is overtly "against/for" a cause and some takes an approach that is a little 'softer'.  It would be helpful to my research to have another look at works that are quite extreme and ones that are less so.


References

Fairey, Shepard, 2014 (most recent update).  Obey Giant - Worldwide Propaganda Delivery. [website] Available at:
http://www.obeygiant.com
[Accessed 5th November 2014]

Heller, Steven, 2004.   AIGA.org.  Interview with Shepard Fairey:  Still Obeying After All These Years. [online article] Available at:  http://www.aiga.org/interview-with-shepard-fairey-still-obeying-after-all-these-year/
[Accessed 5th November 2014]

Images

By Fairey, Shepard:

Figure 1: 1994.  Andre The Giant Has A Posse - We Know Who You Are [online image] Available at:
http://www.obeygiant.com/bootlegs/andre-the-giant-has-a-posse-we-know-who-you-are
[Accessed 5th November 2014]

Figure 2: 2013.  Scale Tipping Print.  18 x 24 inch screen print. [online image] Available at:
http://www.obeygiant.com/prints/scale-tipping-print
[Accessed 5th November 2014]

Figure 3: Unknown. More Militerry Less Skools. 18 x 24 inch screen print. [online image] Available at:
http://www.obeygiant.com/prints/more-militerry
[Accessed 5th November 2014]

Figure 4: 2014.  Home Invasion 2.  18 x 24 inch screen print. [online image] Available at:
http://www.obeygiant.com/prints/home-invasion-2
[Accessed 5th November 2014]

Figure 5: 2014.  Paint It Black. 18 x 24 inch screen print on Speckletone paper. [online image] Available at:  http://www.obeygiant.com/prints/paint-it-black-hand
[Accessed 5th November 2014]

Figure 6: 2014. Paradise Turns.  18 x 24 inch screen print. [online image] Available at:
http://www.obeygiant.com/prints/paradise-turns
[Accessed 5th November 2014]

Figure 7: 2014. People's Climate March To Change Everything. 18 x 24 inch screen print on Speckletone paper. [online image] Available at:
http://www.obeygiant.com/prints/peoples-climate-march-to-change-everything-we-need-everyone.
[Accessed 5th November 2014]

Figure 8: 2013.  BNE x Shepard Fairey.  18 x 24 inch screen print. [online image] Available at:
http://www.obeygiant.com/prints/bne-x-shepard-fairey
[Accessed 5th November 2014]




Tuesday, 4 November 2014

Examining propagandic images from "Graphic Agitation"

A few weeks ago my lecturer Dave was kind enough to lend me both editions of the Graphic Agitation books published by Phaidon, which showcase propaganda of various intentions from the sixties to the nineties.  As I have started looking at propaganda properly now I felt it was about time I finally wrote a bit on it.   There was so much in the first edition alone that this blog post will be on the first book only, and I will write another on the second book.  This book was published in 1995 so focuses on political graphics from the 1960s to the 1990s.

The images in the book cover a range of topics from political to ethical, so here I tried to group them together into subject matter.  All of the images are heavily rooted in visual persuasion, either opposing events and urging for their reversal (nuclear disarment, the Vietnam War, apartheid) or promoting awareness on issues and practises (the AIDS awareness movement, feminism and anti-rape culture).  For the most part all images are white propaganda, i.e. they hide nothing and are open and clear about their message and aims of persuading the public.

"Politics is essentially about power and control, and most of the graphic material in this collection is discussed as part of a struggle for, or against, power." (McQuinton, 1995)

Nuclear Disarment


Fig. 1.1 Humourous advertising was key in removing the opposing power's integrity 
Nuclear disarmament was a huge issue in the sixties and a tough negotiation between the governments of various countries and their respective publics.  Many posters such as Fig. 1.4 gave a clear message about the movement for peace and the impact this would have on nuclear weapons (i.e they would be stopped).  Other works such as the ones shown in Fig.  produced by the Center for the Study of Political Graphics in 1991 opposing the Gulf War.  These posters hit at emotions, with one poster showing men in balaclavas engulfed in a radioactive layer suggesting the environmental consequences, and another showing a robot holding a missile with the words '50,000 lives per gallon' on his screen chest.  Others, such as Figs.1.1 use humorous imagery in an attempt to desensitise the situation and strip the authority of some of their emotional control over people.

Fig. 1.2 

Fig. 1.3 Visual puns by Shigeo Fukuda
Visual puns often hint at phallic objects, for example in the poster on the right of Fig. 1.1 (which is aptly titled "The Seducer") and Shigeo Fukuda's sexual/nuclear pun in Figure 1.3 titled "Victory 1945", designed to show Japan's support for the anti-Vietnam war protests.   Fukuda is noted in the text as being an avid user of visual puns and subversive imagery, so I will be looking at his work soon.

Fig.1.4

The continuing use of subject matter (the nuclear missile) showed the collective desire to make the public aware of the issue.  The image of the missile itself is threatening and therefore acts as a call to action for the public to join the disarmament movement.

Ethnical issues

Fig. 2.1 
"The oppression of indigenous peoples in many countries around the world has been an ongoing subject for graphic protest and focus for the past three decades."(p117, McQuinton, 1995) Many people in the Western world underwent a cultural shift in the 1980s-90s where they began to feel a solidarity for those who were living in oppressed countries or were of an ethic origin that had been persecuted.  Some posters urged people to consider the heritage of others  (Fig. 2.1 "You Are On Aboriginal Land"), others present a satirical view on events with an evident distate, such as the board game by Doug Minkler which highlights and pokes fun at the voyage of Columbus which we now know did more harm than good to indigenous peoples.

Fig. 2.2 - Multilayered messaging in GUOPW poster
The poster above for the General Union of Palestinian Women shows a multilayered message about the oppressive systems against women in the country.  The woman's chained handcuffs breaking apart visually state the aims of the Union, which is to liberate women of the chains of Palestinian society.  She wears a hijab which has a mesh wire pattern, implying that the women of the time felt imprisoned by society.  Visual rhetoric translates as "We want to be free."

  Tommi Ungerer's "Black Power, White Power" from 1967 is another example of visual rhetoric being prevalent just through illustration.  The poster has been truncated a little bit, but it is clear that in this piece of work there is no upside or downside.  Rather, the black and white figures feed on one another no matter what way the poster is viewed.  The message is evident without any additional text - racism is a vicious cycle that benefits neither side.  


Fig. 2.3 "Black Power, White Power"


Public health issues

"..the 1990s have been rocked by the continual surfacing of social crises, some of which have been highly explosive.  The effects of the global threat of AIDS have become a haunting spectre, and promise a difficult future…" (p176, McQuinton, 1995)  "Consequently social issues - or the 'values' with which the 1990s define social wellbeing - have become a battle ground.  They rest high on the political agendas of governments; are argued and debated through the media; and have brought renewed interest in the concepts of social responsibility in design and community art."

I found this example in Fig. 3.1 pretty interesting as it links propaganda with a brand identity, very similar to my own plans for my honours project.  At first glance I thought the Death Cigarettes brand was a tongue-in-cheek take on the packing of cigarettes which traditionally carry warnings of the health consequences of cigarettes.  The description in the book however notes that the brand "challenges the lies and hypocrisy of cigarette advertising by projecting a totally "honest" and upfront message.  It represents a new form of anti-smoking message. "  The poster advert makes a powerful dual statement with both the coffin and "Your Name Here".  "The Death message is an obvious distortion of advertising tactics, used to drive home a harrowing message."


Fig. 3.1 Death Cigarettes campaign
Fig. 3.2 AIDS awareness campaign

  This poster for AIDS awareness looks like a fashion or beauty advertisement which draws the gaze in - until the fine print is read.  The image on the left reads: "If this woman had the virus which could lead to AIDS, in a few years she could look like the person over the page." The image on the right: "Worrying isn't it."  This non-visceral method of highlighting the dangers of HIV and how it can go unnoticed raised public awareness in a way that was far more accessible to non-HIV sufferers.   The woman looks like someone you might see on the street, which plants the thought of "it could be me/anyone" and moves away from the stigma of ill/dying people which surrounds AIDS. 

The anti-AIDS/safe sex campaigns were interestingly marketed to different people depending on the country. "..in Africa, heterosexuals are most vulnerable; in northern Europe, gay men.  Tolerance levels differ with regard to 'indecent' imagery, often resulting in the use of visual metaphors…" (p191, McQuinton, 1995) For example, the "Condoman" poster was created for the Aboriginal audience in south Australia, where the cartoony, superhero was illustrated to match the audience's ethnicity and the metaphor could be understood.  Had it been used in the UK or the US, it may have been met with criticism for it's approach. 


Fig. 3.3

Blunt visual rhetoric

Issues surrounding drugs, accidental pregnancies and unethical fashion practise often used quite visceral imagery in order to get the message home to young people who were more inlined to ignore it.  The images in this section do not fall into one particular category, except that they all exhibit visuals that need little text accompaniment yet cause the viewer to re-think an issue.


Fig. 4.1

Anti-pregancy campaigns are almost exclusively aimed at women, while safe sex campaigns centred around the AIDS awareness movement rather than unwanted pregnancies.  This poster by Cramer Saatchi promoted contraception to men with the question: "Would you be more careful if it was you that got pregnant?" This style of rhetoric made men ask themselves if they were being careful enough.

Fig. 4.2
"Skincare by heroin"  - not a message that can be misunderstood!  Facial imagery draws people in on an emotional level and is central in regular skincare adverts.  This subversion of regular advertising culture is shocking and to the point.

Fig. 4.3

This anti-racist advert promoting T-shirts from a fashion line plays with the semiotic sign for binning rubbish.  The figure shown throwing away the swastika sends a clear message to the public, and using fashion as the setting gives anti-racism a fresh platform.


Fig. 4.4

The "40 Dumb Animals" campaign by the Lynx group (founded by the core members of Greenpeace) was aimed at stopping the use of real fur in fashion.  The billboard poster above was designed in conjunction with a cinematic advert, which showed a catwalk show with models dragging fur along the runway, leaving a trail of blood in its wake.  By pointing the finger at those who buy fur ("But only one to wear it") the poster publicly shames the fur trade and its customers.  McQuinton writes (p220, 1995) "The campaign…played a role in damaging the industry; fur shops were boycotted, fur sales plummeted and the British public's attitude towards fur-wearing changed significantly." 

Fig. 4.5


Fig. "An important event that furthered the use of graphic design to address global issues occurred in the early 1980s, when the Japan Graphic Designers Association launched it's poster series 'Hiroshima Appeals'.  It was accompanied by an annual exhibition of posters on peace which has continued ever since, expanding it's message in the 1990s to include another crucial survival issue: the environment." (p85, McQuinton, 1995)  The Hiroshima remembrance campaign takes place yearly, and this poster from 1983 shows the additional element of the environmental disaster an atomic bomb explosion can cause.  Butterflies represent the fragility of the eco-system which is affected by nuclear explosions.  In addition, butterflies are seen as the souls of the living and the dead in Japanese culture, which bring joy and love.  The cultural implications of them burning visually represents the devastation of Hiroshima on the people of Japan.  

Cultural context

"Censorship and levels of tolerance - whether by the ruling party or the public itself - are issues that vary greatly between the countries represented and allow interesting visual comparisons to be made." (p9, McQinton, 1995)
One example I found in the book was the contrast between the suffrage campaigns in the UK and the US in the early 1900s.  In Fig. which is are works by British artists, suffragettes are shown to be women taking action, and then increasingly so  - see "Jump on him, he is only a mere man".  In contrast, the Mucha-like, kind of angelic image shown in Fig. was a American approach to reflect their intentions of a peaceful approach to obtaining a vote for women.  The soft orangey yellow tones and the sun conveniently forming a halo around the beautiful woman's head give a clear message of warmth and anti-agression.  McQuinton writes " …the stylised realism of art nouveau, so prevalent at the time, served to undermine the 'ugly suffragette' theory and keep the tone soft yet persuasive…particularly with the case of American posters, where persuasion often took the form of a 'civilised' appeal to mean for reform and justice.  The British movement, on the other hand, was highly publicised for its aggressive militancy, and consequently its posters were more assertive."(p19, 1995)
This can be seen in  Fig. with vibrant reds and yellows used, which together with a cartoony style present a quite violent illustration.    This idea of Britain being slightly more avant-garde with it's ideas is continued as McQuinton (p9, 1995) writes: "The billboard showing Margaret Thatcher hanging by a noose on page 49 lasted only a few days in Britain, but it is unlikely that it's equivalent would ever have been displayed in America." (p7, 1995) This throws up the aspect of cultural context, which I should mentally flag for later as this will be a useful area of research for both branding and propaganda.  Cultural context is an important question for all designers to ask themselves.

Fig. 5.1
Fig. 5.2


Political campaigns


Fig. 6.1

"Up to the mid 1980s, 'politics' usually inferred party politics.  But with the build-up of 'awareness' activities - including charity rock events such as Live Aid, pressure groups campaigning for new attitudes towards peace and the environment, and style magazines promoting activism and human rights - the term politics has grown more and more to signify popular movements relating to social issues.  This has evolved into the 1990s trend towards 'personal politics', an individual awareness and concern for world problems, and a sense of responsibility to self, friends and family, society and the planet as a whole…" (p7, McQuinton 1995)  Humour and satire featured heavily in this book as many graphic artists chose to get the public on their side with a relatable element rather than a heavy message.  The example in Fig. is a parody of "See No Evil, Hear No Evil, Speak No Evil", transformed into "We know! We dare! We do!" to support the election of three candidates to the Hungarian Parliament.  "The candidates strike a pose that is intentionally opposite to the classical three monkeys.  Instead they mime "I hear! I see! I speak!" to accompany the text of the title.  In the foreground there are the symbols as they apply to each candidate: anti-Communism (a muzzled red dog), the withdrawal of Russian troops, and the right way forward to a new future." (p65, McQuinton, 1995)


Fig 6.2 EAT by Tommi Ungerer

"EAT" by Tommi Ungerer is a different kind of political campaign, one that hits out against America's imposing its values to other countries.  The Statue of Liberty is shown being shoved down a person's throat.  The symbolism of the statue and what it stands for is used as a device for a visual rhetoric - "Lady Liberty" is being fed to someone against their will, an ironic juxtaposition of ideas.  The whiteness of the hand and the statue represent the Caucasian identity of America, while the figure whose mouth is being forced open is suggested to be of a different background.  To me there is an underlying suggestion of being force fed and expected to be thankful for it.

Environmental issues

A combination of events from the 1980s - increased solidarity towards third world countries, nuclear accidents such as Tchernobyl and the advent of the greenhouse effect - changed the way people were now viewing environmental.  "This shift in attitude dramatically changed the way that creative artists viewed and handled environmental issues.  No longer considered 'soft subjects' , environmental issues became part of the cutting edge.  Old graphic cliche´s - drawings of cute, cuddly animals and exotic photographs of majestic wildlife - did not completely lose their attraction, but the range of environmental comments, and the visual methods used to convey them, expanded enormously." (p223, McQuinton, 1995)


Fig 7.1 ECOVER campaign
ECOVER created these posters during a street art project, where volunteers created works by "cutting and tearing up redundant advertising posters." This not only created the graphic cliches described above but upheld ECOVER's values of minimising their damage to the environment.  Slogans such as "from your drain to the ocean" visually show that the ingredients used in their products are environment friendly and biodegradable.

Fig. 7.2 
An image of a fish killed by pollution from the Exxon Valdez oil spill.  Today this would not be so relevant but at the time it was a pressing issue as the impact of the oil spill spread through eco system issues to the seafood economy on the southwest coast of America.  There is small fine print at the bottom and a graph depicting damage, but eve without this the image is clear and quite hard-hitting.

The findings from this book have shown me various techniques used in the practise of white (overt) propaganda, in particular the use of humour to disarm serious topics, manipulation of known visual conventions ("Keep Britain Tidy" and "Skincare by Heroin", for example) and the importance of a cultural context in the effective translation of a visual metaphor.  Next I will be looking at the follow-on to the Graphic Agitation book, which looks at propaganda in the social media age.

References

McQuinton, Liz, 1994. Graphic Agitation: Social and Political Graphics since the Sixties [ London:  Phaidon]

Images

Fig 1.1 Themptander, C, 1981.  Attention! Printed collage, Stockholm
Fig 1.1 (right) Themptander, C, 1984.  The Seducer.  Printed collage, Stockholm

Fig 1.2:  Potter, Keith R and Lyons, Stephen 1990. No Blood For Oil.  Printed poster, United States
Fig 1.2:  (right) Multiple authors, 1990. US Out of The Middle East. Printed poster, United States
Fig 1.3:  Fukuda, Shigeo, 1975. Victory 1945.  Printed poster, Japan
Fig 1.4:  Kennard, Peter, 1979.  Protest and Survive.  Printed poster, United States

Fig 2.1:  Minkler, Doug, 1992. Columbusters.  Printed poster, United States
Fig 2.1:  (right) McMahon, Marie, 1981. You are on aboriginal land.  Printed poster, Canberra, Australia
Fig 2.2:  Mansour, J, 1980. Poster for the General Union of Palestine Women.  Printed poster, Palestine
Fig 3.1:  Unknown, 1991. Death Cigarettes.  Brand identity product line. United Kingdom
Fig 3.2:  Bailey, David, 1989. Magazine ad for the Health Education Authority. Printed magazine advertisement, United Kingdom
Fig 3.3:  Redbax Graphics, 1987. Condoman. Printed poster, Canberra, Australia

Fig 4.1:  Cramer and Saatchi, 1970. Contraception Advertisement for the Health Education Council.  Printed poster, United Kingdom
Fig. 4.2: Yellowhammer agency, 1989. Skincare by Heroin. Printed poster, United Kingdom
Fig 4.3:  Rutschli, P and Blame, Judy, 1992 Keep Britain Tidy.  Photographic advertisement poster, United Kingdom
Figure 4.4:  Bailey, David, 1985.  40 Dumb Animals, Printed poster, United Kingdom
Fig 4.5:  Unknown, 1983.  Hiroshima Appeals, Printed illustration, Japan

Fig 5.1:  Rigby, Reginald, 1913. Suffragettes.  Lithographic print, United Kingdom
Fig 5.1 (right):  Unknown, 1910. Suffragettes on the War Path. Lithographic print, United Kingdom
Fig 5.2:  Boye, B.M, 1913.  Votes for Women. Lithographic illustration, United States

Fig 6.1:  Pocs, Peter, 1990. We know! We dare! We do! Mixed media photography and painting, Hungary
Fig 6.2:  Ungerer, Tommi, 1967.  Black Power, White Power.  Printed lithographic poster, United States

 Figure 7.1:  Gonzalez, Bickel et al, 1992.  Recycled Advertising Street Project.  Mixed media collage and poster, United Kingdom
Figure 7.2:  Akagi, Powell, 1992.  Save San Francisco Bay.  Printed poster, California, United States















Sunday, 2 November 2014

Anti-branding communities

I felt that it was important to look at anti-branding, as I have been encouraged to take an approach that is different to a regular branding project and it might prove insightful to certain aspects of brand connotations.  While it relates less to the visual persuasion element of branding, knowing why people oppose brands could also inform how I go about creating them as there would be certain aspects that people have identified as turning them off which I could either avoid or amplify depending on my approach.  The first article I write about in this post is titled Consumer Activism on the Internet: The Role of Anti-brand Communities, and it's focus is mainly on groups that are anti-corporation.  It is a little dates (published in 2006) but I found a lot that was relevant still.  The three main groups examined in this study were anti-Wal-Mart, anti-McDonalds and anti-Starbucks, and the communities existed online.  The study examined the four main factors in a person's decision to oppose a brand, and the effect being part of an online community had on their lives.

To give a little more context, the introduction states that: "The purpose of this study is to understand the nature of online, anti-brand communities as an emergent social movement.  The investigation is guided by three research questions.  First, why do online anti-brand communities from?  Second, what behavioural manifestations are associated with anti-brand community involvement?  Third, in what ways are emerging technologies influencing and interacting with consumer activist strategies?" (Hollenbeck and Zinkhan, 2006)  While this paper is really more focused on the psychological aspects of anti-branding, I feel an understanding of this is important to help my research.

Brand relationships and break-ups

 "Consumers not only form relationships with brands, they form relationships with other consumers that have similar brand preferences...Brand communicates are network of consumer relationships that situate a commonly used brand.  These communities create a sense of belonging among consumers and the brand becomes the central purpose and meaning for group interaction. " (Hollenbeck and Zinkhan, 2006)   This is an area I need to explore more, in both research and practical work, and will probably feature in posts I have coming on brand narratives too.  Without customer relationships a brand cannot be sustained - sure, initial business from first-time customers will happen but this will not continue if there is not a promise fulfilled or a connection made between consumer and company.  The article mentions Starbucks as a prime target for an anti-brand community, but Starbucks also has a relationship with its customers based on quality of ingredients, choice, charity investment and personal touches such as the recent named orders scheme running in shops.   Starbucks also "give back" by gifting customers with free e-books and albums from iTunes, so the customer can easily feel that there is a sense of the company giving back to them even as they hand over their money.  One Starbucks customer will identify with others through their choice of coffee chain, and by extension, the perks of this coffee chain - similar tastes merge and there is a small sense of community.  The same could be said of Converse shoes, which are heavily ingrained in the fashion that follows the rock/punk/alternative music culture.  Those whose dress is influenced by their music tastes will often be seen wearing the shoes as part of a dress style that marks them as fans of a particular kind of music.  Of course, this is one sweeping example, and Converse's reach far extends that of young people who alternative bands, but one of several clothing trends which link this demographic together is very often their common choice in the footwear brand.  I could give many more examples of this, but the point is that brands thrive on a relationship not just between them and the customer, but also the customer and other customers.

The reversal of this is also addressed as an opening to the main topic of the paper.  It is noted that
"…brands also have potential to symbolise negative perceptions associated with corporations.  The antithesis of a brand community is an anti-brand community.  In the same way that brand communities are forming around commonly used brands, ant--brand communities are forming around common aversions to brands." (Hollenbeck and Zinkhan, 2006).  This is interesting as it poses the question of whether disliking something is a stronger bonding force than liking something - general consensus says that love wins out, but hate propaganda does have an effect if the other factors are in place.  Anti-idea groups and movements have many things in common with specific anti-brand movements as they both stem from public dissatisfaction.  However, "The anti-brand movement...also has some unique aspects.  First, the anti-brand movement represents a confluence of ideas.  For example, this issues prominent in the anti-brand movement range from workplace equality to corporate domination to environmentalism and marketing propaganda." Following on from this, "In the twenty-first century, many consumers view corporations as dominating and oppressive by means of imbalanced distribution systems of deceitful marketing tactics." (Dobscha, 1998)

Why do people choose an anti-brand approach?

The paper identified four factors that drive people to join anti-brand communities, particularly the ones the writers looked into.  "Data analysis revealed four distinct reasons why anti-brand communities from: 1) to provide a social community comprised of members with common moral obligation, 2) to provide a support network to achieve common goals, 3) to provide a way of coping with workplace difficulties, and 4) to provide a resource hub for taking action."  (Hollenbeck and Zinkhan, 2006).  These findings could be informative for myself, particularly the aspect of social community, support network and call for change.  From the perspectives of propaganda, visual persuasion and branding, these elements can crucial to forming a connection which is a main factor that causes people to act.  The four factors identified also form a kind of overarching narrative which drives the movement and participation in it.   The movement is almost always carried out on the internet, due to the ease of spreading ideas and interacting with others.   Hollenbeck and Zinkhan (2006) write that "The Internet has changed the way people participate in social action…it has enabled anti-brand communities to proliferate online in unprecedented numbers." Online is the ideal setting for social communities to act out en masse, as communication is centralised, instant and members of forums can respond together to topics or events.   "Today, social movements are transpiring in virtual space, which sets the stage for new forms of protest, organisation, co-operation and coalition-building.  The Internet plays a major role in the anti-brand movement because it provides communication methods for people around the globe irrespective of geographical space and time zones." (Hollenbeck and Zinkhan, 2006)

A sense of community

  An Internet forum or website is also a platform that arguably has less barriers in both a physical and communicative sense, as anyone can reach out to anyone online. Naturally, when this is possibly in a place where many people share opinions, a sense of affinity develops.  "When asked to describe their anti-brand community, participants used similar terms such as "family", "friends", and "support" when telling stories about their website communities. Anti-brand communities provide the supportive, family-like environment necessary to achieve common goals."  So what we can take from this is again the sense of community which is vital to driving the movement, and on the flip side, how this same approach can drive a brand's success.  Continuing this sentiment: "The website acts as a gathering place  for individuals to become and feel authentic.  Through a process of advising and counselling one another, community members engage in a course of self-improvement…"

"I Hate Starbucks" home page

So, why do people act out against corporate brands in the first place? I looked at the site I Hate Starbucks (despite the sacrilege to my 16-year-old-self), whose homepage proclaims among other things that "...small businesses and independent cafes that gave our neighbourhoods and towns such a unique flavour are forced out of business in favour of overprices, over sugared and ultimately unhealthy and uncreative options…"  The obvious outcry here is about the false image projected from Starbucks about ethical business practices and corporations taking over small businesses.  This sentiment is echoed by the findings of the paper, where many people oppose the companies because of the manipulated messages they send out to their consumers, which a large amount of the public act on despite there being very little truth in them.  The aforementioned "Anti-Branding" paper quotes findings from Firat and Ventakesh (1995): "...corporations are perceived by some as using sophisticated promotional techniques to attach world-wide meanings to their brands.  Consumers who internalise these meanings implicitly grant corporations the cultural authority to dictate their values, tastes and preferences." The backlash against this leads to "consumer groups resisting imposed meanings or values that are prescribed by a brand…the brand name serves as a negative symbolisation by representing corporation domination." (Firat and Ventakesh, 1995)

 So the effect of this is that "Anti-brand communities create a virtual reality that fosters utopian thinking.  These communities are visionary, creating ideal, social and political schemes.  The interactions among community members are based upon visionary ideals of urban planning, activist projects and controlled consumption lifestyles." (Hollenebeck and Zinkhan, 2006)

Research findings in relation to my project


The main questions this research has raised for me is, what is it that makes is interact with brands the way we do?  Our relationships with a brand are 95% engineered by the companies behind them, but what is that 5% that makes us behave from our own ways?  What would happen if I took an approach that was not quite anti-branding but encouraged less consumption?  A good example of this in today's market would be the likes of Lush, who use fair-trade ingredients, don't test on animals, urge customers to return packaging and market the shelf life of a product clearly so that buyers can be aware of not wasting it.  
The element of a community movement was also of key interest as it was the part of the anti-branding communities that resonated most with regular brand communities.  I think that the idea of linking people to each other through mutual interests and beliefs will be very helpful to my work - it can also be argued that this is a key factor in propaganda movements, which some anti-brand communities end up becoming.  My next bit of research will be to read the book "No Logo" by Naomi Klein, and then experiment with some minimalist visuals that can discourage the mindset of the typical "over-consumer".

-

References

Firat, Fuat and Alladi Ventakesh (1995). Liberatory Postmodernism and the Reenchentment of Consumption. Journal of Consumer Research, 22 (December) 239-67

Hollenbeck, C.R, and Zinkhan, G.M, 2006.  Consumer Activism on the Internet: The Role of Anti-brand Communities. Advances in Consumer Research, [e-journal] 33.   Available at:
http://www.acrwebsite.org/volumes/v33/v33_10337.pdf
[Accessed 20th October 2014]

Author unknown, date unknown.  I Hate Starbucks [online] Available at: http://www.ihatestarbucks.com 
[Accessed 01 November 2014]